Пинк флойд With The Beatles????????

Пинк флойд пели альбом With The Beatles??
Если нет то что это такое?

ed2k://|file|pink.floyd.-.With.The.Beatles.On.April.15,.1967_Very.rare.mp3|152017420|16D4353A34C90D3B1A61AA885AEC79FD|/

Ну учитывая что Piper At The Gates of Dawn и Sgt.Pepper записывались в одно время в соседних студиях на Abbey Road - вполне возможно что что-то и было.

У меня в коллекции есть например вот такой файлик:
Pink_Floyd_-_What_a_shame_Mary_Jane__With_The_Beatles_On_April_15,_1967_Very_rare_.mp3

Дата совпадает. Правда там запись всего на минуту с небольшим да и качество хромает...

Хм, ну что же... поставлю на закачку пускай скачается... любопытно...

What the shame вышла в релизе (не знаю, официальный ли)
a tree full of secrets. качество нормальное, учитывая, сколько ЛСД
сьел Сид... вот вопрос к знатокам: у меня есть каверы в исполнении Флойдов как то: School's out for summer, House of rising sun.
Не могу сказать, что слышно кто поет. может блеф.
Кто слышал, подскажите.
Спасибо

School's out for summer, House of rising sun - ничего не слышал об этих каверах, скорее всего это фейки.

Treefull - это бутлег, а где вы нашли на нем этот трек?
Что касается участия PF в записи этой песни, вот отрывок с Echoes FAQ:

9. Did Syd play on the Beatles' 'What's the Shame Mary Jane'? *
[Thanks to Gerhard and Chris Fleming:]
The song, often appearing on early Floyd RoIOs, is a Beatles outtake. Its proper title is "What's the New Mary Jane?" and there are (I think) four versions available by the Beatles. All Beatles-related sources state that "What's the New" is a Lennon song that is given a Lennon/McCartney song writing credit for contractual reasons. There is some similarity between this track and the early Floyd material -- the song sounds like a cross between Revolution 9 and a normal Beatles song.

To the best of anyone's knowledge, there is no mention of any involvement by Syd on this track (or any other Beatles track for that matter) in any Beatles-related book or article. The only places that link Syd to this song are RoIOs, fanzines and computer forums. Final proof that Syd is not on this song is given by Chris Fleming, who wrote:


I have Mark Lewisohn's book THE BEATLES RECORDING SESSIONS. It tells that "What's the New Mary Jane?" was in fact recorded on August 14 1968 during the White Album sessions. In writing the book Lewisohn listened to the original session tapes, and in the book lists in some cases musicians hired for the sessions. I am sure that if Syd had indeed played on this song that Mr. Lewisohn would have found it out through listening to the tapes, studio documentation, or interviews with the engineers.
The "famous" meeting between Pink Floyd and the Beatles took place on March 21, 1967. Syd's 1968 recording dates were May 6th, 14th, 21st and 28th; June 8th and 20th; and July 20th. In other words, Syd does *NOT* appear on this track.

What A Shame, Mary Jane Had A Pain At The Party
Label Apples
Catalogue No. APPLES 1002
Matrix No.'s 11707325 08471 ... and ...
R035-0101-5146
Country Of Origin Japan
Release date 1996
Total time 65:26
1 What's The New, Mary Jane Take 4 RS1 - Stereo edited version for planned single 3:12
2 You Know My Name (Look Up The Number) Test pressing version (same as single ?) 4:16
3 What's The New, Mary Jane Kinfaun's acoustic demo - George's house May 1968 2:36
4 What's The New, Mary Jane Stereo mix made for the aborted "Sessions" album. 6:02
5 What's The New, Mary Jane Stereo remix made for the aborted "Sessions" album. Same as Anthology 3 6:02
6 What's The New, Mary Jane Take 4 6:48
7 What's The New, Mary Jane Take 4 with extra chat at end and opposite channels to the next track. 6:33
8 What's The New, Mary Jane Take 4 RS1 (Side A of the 12") 6:32
9 What's The New, Mary Jane Take 4 RS5 made 26th November 1969 (Side B of the 12") 7:02
10 What's The New, Mary Jane Take 4 RM1 - Edited single version (same as track 1 !) 3:12
11 Not Guilty Mono "Sessions" mix 3:12
12 Not Guilty Take 102 4:21
13 Not Guilty Stereo "Sessions" mix 3:20
14 You Know My Name (Look Up The Number) John's piano demo from March 1968 1:01

anthology 3
What's The New Mary Jane
Originally conceived by John for use on the White Album, then rejected, then considered as a B-side for the Plastic Ono Band to "You Know My Name (Look Up The Number)", "What's The New Mary Jane" was never issued except on bootleg discs. This is take 4, featuring John and George as well as Yoko and Mal Evans on sound effects.

Этот пинк флойд с битлз оказлся полным фэйком. На самом деле это ACDs..